| Evaluation Criteria for Internet
Research There
are some basic criteria you should review when evaluating
a website for its quality of information. The reason you
want to carefully evaluate a website is that anyone can
publish on the Web. Currently, there are no editors, fact-checkers
or web standards that exit to ensure accuracy. The
following websites provide questions that you should ask/answer
about a website concerning Accuracy, Authority,
Objectivity, Currency and Coverage.
Web Research Evaluation Checklist
(University of Louisville Libraries)
Evaluation Criteria (New Mexico
State University Library)
Briefly, the criteria are:
- Accuracy -- You want
to make sure the information is reliable, error-free
and there is an editor or someone who verifies
the information.
- Authority -- You want
to know who is the author, whether the author is
qualified or an expert, who's sponsoring the page
and is the sponsor reputable. Hence if you look
at the domain (.edu, .com, .gov, .org, .net), it
gives you an idea of who is the publisher.
- Objectivity -- You
want to check to see if there are any biases,
whether the information is free of advertising or
whether the page is designed to influence opinion.
- Currency -- You want
to check to see if the page is dated, when it was
last updated or any other information about
whether or not the page is kept current.
- Coverage -- You want
to check to see if the page is completed or under
construction. If the material is based on a print
resource, is it the full-text or only part of the
text and is it the current version or an outdated
version. Not that you can't use an abridged
version of the text or an older version, but you
need to know that's what you're using.
If you carefully evaluate a
webpage based on the criteria listed above, you will have
a good sense of the quality of the resource.
|